A deeply personal story has found its way into Marshals, giving Mo Brings Plenty an opportunity to honor his late nephew, Cole Brings Plenty, through a storyline that reflects the painful experiences his family continues to face. The actor, who has been part of the Yellowstone universe since 2018, admitted that revisiting the circumstances surrounding his nephew’s death through his character was emotionally difficult.
The Season 2 episode titled Roughstock places Mo at the center of an investigation involving his missing nephew, Troy. Although the fictional story develops differently from the real-life events involving Cole, its emotional foundation comes directly from the actor’s family’s experience.
For Mo, bringing this storyline to television was not simply another acting assignment. It was an opportunity to raise awareness about unresolved cases affecting Indigenous communities and give a voice to families searching for answers.
A Story Inspired by the Loss of Cole Brings Plenty
Cole Brings Plenty, Mo’s 27-year-old nephew, went missing in March 2024. His body was discovered in Kansas the following month.
Before his death, Cole had begun building an acting career of his own. He appeared as Pete Plenty Clouds in the Yellowstone prequel series 1923, following a path that had also brought his uncle recognition in the entertainment industry.
The circumstances surrounding Cole’s disappearance and death became a deeply painful subject for his family. Before his body was found, Cole had been identified as a suspect in a domestic violence incident. The Lawrence Police Department later stated that investigators had found no indication of foul play, while the Johnson County Sheriff’s Office said it had conducted a thorough investigation.
However, Mo and his family have continued expressing concerns about how the case was handled. The actor has publicly questioned whether his nephew’s death received the investigation it deserved and has repeatedly called for further attention to the circumstances.
In March 2026, Mo told The Hollywood Reporter that his family was not prepared to let the matter go.
Those experiences eventually became the foundation for one of Marshals Season 2’s most emotionally significant episodes.
How Cole’s Story Became Part of Marshals

In Roughstock, Mo’s character learns that his nephew Troy, played by Will Strongheart, has disappeared. Worried about his family’s safety and desperate for answers, Mo turns to Kayce Dutton, portrayed by Luke Grimes, for help.
Kayce becomes personally involved in the search, even going beyond the normal boundaries of his position as a U.S. Marshal.
When Kayce and Mo eventually discover Troy’s body on a mountain, the circumstances surrounding his death raise serious questions. Kayce asks Andrea Cruz, played by Ash Santos, to find a way to bring the investigation under the Marshals’ authority.
The investigation initially leads them to two poachers who had encountered Troy shortly before his death. Although the men were connected to the events surrounding Troy’s final moments, they were not responsible for harming him.
The evidence ultimately establishes that Troy was murdered rather than having died by suicide. However, the identity of the person responsible remains unknown, leaving Mo determined to seek justice for his nephew.
The episode concludes with an Indigenous ceremony honoring Troy’s life, giving the storyline an emotional ending while leaving room for further developments.
According to executive producer Spencer Hudnut, the original idea involved a former teammate of Kayce dying under mysterious circumstances. The creative team subsequently developed the storyline into something much more personal after discussing Mo’s family’s experience with him.
Hudnut explained that he first approached the actor to ask whether he would feel comfortable portraying such a sensitive subject. Mo welcomed the idea.
The actor and his brother, who is Cole’s father, had previously shared their experiences with the show’s creative team. The writers then worked to incorporate those real-life concerns into the fictional investigation.
Mo Brings Plenty Says Reliving the Experience Was Difficult

Although Mo agreed to participate, filming the episode required him to revisit memories that remained deeply painful.
In an interview with TV Insider, the actor acknowledged that the experience was emotionally challenging. However, he also described completing the episode as a small step toward healing.
He explained that after filming ended, he felt he had regained some strength following a prolonged period of feeling overwhelmed by the family’s circumstances.
For Mo, the opportunity to portray a character fighting for answers offered something he had struggled to find in real life: the possibility of being heard.
He emphasized that the episode was not intended solely to represent his own family. Many Indigenous families experience similar difficulties when trying to obtain answers about missing or deceased relatives.
The actor hopes the storyline will encourage people across the country to speak up, contact their political representatives and demand greater attention to cases affecting Native American communities.
He also stressed the importance of ensuring that law enforcement agencies properly investigate these situations rather than allowing unresolved cases to remain overlooked.
Luke Grimes and Gil Birmingham Helped Mo Through the Emotional Scenes
The support of his fellow cast members played an important role in helping Mo bring the story to the screen.
The actor specifically praised Luke Grimes and Gil Birmingham, explaining that both understood what his family had experienced.
Their awareness of the situation made it easier for him to be emotionally vulnerable during filming. Mo described them as brothers in real life, people he could turn to when the material became particularly difficult.
He also appreciated working with Will Strongheart, who portrayed Troy. Strongheart was familiar with the circumstances that inspired the storyline, which helped create a greater sense of understanding among those involved in the episode.
Mo’s family also remained involved in supporting the production. He discussed the project with his brother, Cole’s father, while family members maintained their prayers throughout the filming process.
An Indigenous ceremony was also part of the episode, reflecting the importance of honoring the person who had been lost and recognizing the family’s grief.
Why the Episode Matters Beyond the Yellowstone Universe
:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc()/mo-brings-plenty-1-4e57f6d54b4c4d7688f8a9c8146fec6d.jpg)
For Mo, the significance of Roughstock extends well beyond the fictional investigation.
The actor wants viewers to understand that families in Indigenous communities continue to face serious challenges when loved ones go missing or die under uncertain circumstances.
He believes that increased public awareness and stronger support from law enforcement could help bring attention to cases that might otherwise receive insufficient scrutiny.
The episode also continues a broader tradition within the Yellowstone franchise of exploring issues affecting Indigenous communities, particularly through characters connected to the Broken Rock Reservation.
While Troy’s fictional case reaches a different conclusion from the unresolved concerns surrounding Cole’s death, the emotional similarities make the storyline especially meaningful.
Mo hopes that viewers will take the episode as an invitation to listen to Indigenous families, recognize their experiences and support their efforts to seek justice.
By bringing part of his family’s story into Marshals, the actor has transformed a painful personal experience into a television storyline with a wider purpose. His performance serves as a tribute to Cole while drawing attention to families who continue searching for answers of their own.
Marshals airs Sundays on CBS, with new episodes available to stream on Paramount+ the following day.
Source: Compiled from various sources
