Fans of The Voice were left stunned after country singer Manny Costello was sent home by Reba McEntire during Night 3 of the Battles, sparking thousands of posts on social media with the hashtag #BringMannyBack. Many viewers even urged fellow coaches, particularly Snoop Dogg, to sign Manny to a record deal after what they called a controversial result.
The intense battle paired Reba’s country talents, Manny Costello and Leyton Robinson, in a powerful duet that showcased Manny’s soulful, raspy tenor alongside Leyton’s precise, piercing voice.
Both singers delivered exceptional energy and emotion, making Reba’s decision all the more difficult. Ultimately, she chose Leyton, explaining that her choice was based on where she felt she could best support the artist’s growth.
Despite his elimination, Manny left the stage with grace, expressing gratitude to Reba for her mentorship. Fans immediately reacted online, flooding social media with praise and disbelief:
“You got robbed. Keep going.”
“Mannyyy 😭 you are AMAZING… Your voice is really something special.”
“Best voice this season… the minute you started singing, I immediately said to my dad, ‘Oh, he’s going to be famous!!!’”
The #BringMannyBack movement continues to trend, with fans calling on Snoop Dogg and other industry figures to recognize Manny’s talent:
“Snoop, you HAVE to sign this guy! His voice is one of a kind!”
“Manny deserves a record deal yesterday. Please, Snoop, do it!”
Beyond the competition, Manny’s personal story has struck a chord with audiences. During a behind-the-scenes moment, he shared how his journey with music and family are deeply intertwined:
“This song reminds me of my journey with my wife. We met in 10th grade, got married, and now have a beautiful life together. To give her that dream, I had to mow a lot of lawns. Slowly but surely, I found success in the long-carry business. I felt proud when I could give Sydney the life she wanted, and now she’s pushing me to reach the place I want to be in my music career. She’s a big part of why I’m here today.”
Manny’s heartfelt reflections extend to his children as well:
“I love hanging out with my daughters. We cuddle, watch shows together. They love music and love it when I sing. For the blind audition, I sang Craig Morgan’s Almost Home. The song is about a man who doesn’t have much, but I feel very blessed for the people who love me. My daughters mean the world to me. I want to show them that you can do anything you put your mind to. Believe in yourself.”
View this post on Instagram
Even in elimination, Manny’s performances have captivated audiences nationwide, proving that true talent leaves a lasting impression. His soulful country tone, versatility, and authenticity have earned him a passionate fan base and the promise of bigger opportunities ahead—including recording deals and future performances.
The Voice, Season 28, airs Mondays at 8/7c on NBC.
