Locals say Horn Island’s dangerous currents have claimed lives before as questions continue in Nolan Wells’ death

As the investigation into Nolan Wells’ death continues, several people familiar with Mississippi’s Horn Island say the area has a long history of dangerous waters, arguing that even experienced swimmers can quickly find themselves in trouble.

Wells, an 18 year old college football player, disappeared during a Fourth of July trip to Horn Island and was found dead in the water on July 6. Authorities have said preliminary evidence points to an accidental drowning, although the investigation remains ongoing and an official cause of death has not yet been released.

Speaking anonymously to NBC News because of the intense public attention surrounding the case, a local boat operator described the waters around Horn Island as unpredictable and potentially deadly.

“I know people that have grown up out there that have died out there,” the boater said. “It’ll humble you very quick. I don’t care what kind of shape you’re in. Those currents can get you, and before you even realize you’re in trouble, you’re gone.”

The comments come as Wells’ family continues to question whether accidental drowning fully explains what happened.

Civil rights attorney Ben Crump, who represents the family, has argued that Wells was a strong swimmer and believes more questions need to be answered before any conclusions are reached.

Local residents also told NBC News that it is common for large groups of boaters gathering at Horn Island over holiday weekends to socialize with other groups throughout the day.

According to those familiar with the area, visitors often return to the mainland on different boats than the ones they originally arrived on, something they say is considered normal during busy holiday celebrations.

That explanation aligns with statements from some of Wells’ friends, who have told investigators he chose to remain on the island after meeting a young woman while the rest of their group headed back to shore.

The same locals also said it is common for people to leave their phones with friends while swimming or walking through the water to keep the devices dry. Wells’ family has questioned why his phone and keys were not with him when he disappeared.

Despite the local accounts, Wells’ parents continue to push for a full independent investigation.

They have expressed concerns about the official investigation and say they are not convinced their son’s death was simply an accident. Crump has also called for complete transparency as investigators continue reviewing witness statements, cellphone data, GPS records, and forensic evidence.

While authorities have repeatedly said they have found no evidence of foul play so far, they stress the investigation remains active as they await the results of both the official autopsy and the independent examination requested by Wells’ family.